« A Time to Start  •  Business In a Box »

Defending Freedom

April 19, 2007 in Barry's Rant by barry

Over the past 10 years or so, we (Australia) have seen a steady decrease in personal liberties in the name of protecting individual freedom.

This is to me is a little like fighting for peace, ( I would have used the other analogy, but I do need to keep this clean).

The one single issue that has amazed me is that of David Hicks and his internment for 5 years without charge with the complicity of the Australian Government. In the end he will server a few more months and be released.

At no stage in the process did we ever know exactly what he was supposed to have done - other than glib comments about him being a “terrorist” - a catch-all to shut up anyone that has the audacity to question the current administration.

To me the treatment of David Hicks means that no one can actually rely on the accepted notion of innocent until proven guilty, something most of us assumed was our unaliable right as Asutralian citizens. My understandning is that it is this one principal that defines our ‘freedom’. By stripping this from Hicks the current Austrlian Government has set a precident that severly impacts anyone’s freedom to disagree with the authorities. There is no guarantee that you or I won’t be treated in the same disgusting way.
We afford legal process to mass killers (Martin Bryant, Ivan Milat, the Snow Town crowd), who have commited crimes that dwarf the Hicks invovlement in ethnic struggle, but add the word ‘terrorist’ and its OK to treat someone any way you please. We didn’t even insist on application of the Geneva convention.

I wholeheartedly support moves to charge and try anyone that seeks to break the laws of the land, particularly if that includes violence. If Hicks broke the law, he shoud be punished, in accordance with the law. But that did not happen. He was punished first with a detailed and coordinated media assault on his character, but no charges for 5 YEARS!!! When,finally, our Government was embarrassed into ‘managing the situation’ (not through due process), we get the spectacle of a forced confession and a custodial sentence, politically determined to minimise the adverse impact on the government’s polling results.

This government, and particularly the PM and Attorney General should hang their heads in shame, as far as I know they are first to subvert justice in the name of trying to defend it.

As an elector and citizen of Austrlia, I demand a full explanation of why this was allowed to happen, and further :

  • What crimes are so bad that a citizen of Australia can expect to forego due process because someone from another country thinks so?
  • What third party countries are able to kidnap our citizens, hold and torture them without providing legal representation?
  • What is the difference between what the Australian and US Administrations have done to Habib, Hicks and others and the Hezbollah, PLO, Iran have done when they kidnap innocent (remember under our laws, Hick and co were innocent until the court case ended, if they got one) people, hold and torture them? From my reading these folk make the same claims of right that the US and Austrlian Governments did.

I guess the old guy I met when I was young was right when he said “There are no good guys in this“.

RSS Open Source Initiative

  • OSI Reform At FOSDEM
    In preparation for my keynote at FOSDEM, I was interviewed by the team who have just posted the interview. In particular, I noted this background to the governance reform, which readers here might find useful: Why exactly did OSI decide to reorganize its governance from a board-only organization into a member-based structure?read more
  • FLOSS Body of Knowledge
    As courses, certificates, and curricula are created, it's valuable to bring together people who are working to develop and deliver this material into a community where we can jointly define a central body of knowledge related to free, libre, and open source software. That goal has led me to take the first step toward creating this body of knowledge, te […]
  • OSI Opposes SOPA and PIPA
    The Open Source Initiative Board joined many other civil society organizations as co-signatories of an open letter expressing concern about SOPA and PIPA. As human rights and press freedom advocates, we write to express our deep concern about S. 968, the PROTECT IP Act (PIPA), and the threat it poses to international human rights. Like H.R. 3261, the Stop On […]
  • Mozilla Releases OSI-Approved MPLv2
    Last week saw a quiet landmark in the history of the open source movement with the formal release of version two of the Mozilla Public License (MPLv2) and its approval as an official open source license. While to many it may look like just another legal detail, it is significant both for the way it was conducted and for the intent with which it has been cr […]
  • Open Source receives official support in Rio de Janeiro (Brazil)
    On November 11, 2011, the government of the State of Rio de Janeiro - the second largest state in Brazil in terms of population and GDP - published a new law, which mandates public entities and companies in Rio de Janeiro to give preference to open document formats, in particular ODF. The publication of Law #5978/2011 was celebrated in an official event wit […]
  • OSI and the CPTN Transaction
    This page preserves the news flow from the OSI home page at the start of 2011 concerning the purchase of Novell's patent portfolio by the CPTN Consortium. read more
  • Cape Verde's Big Win
    Last week it was announced that former Cape Verde president Pedro Pires won the $5 million Mo Ibrahim prize for exceptional African leadership. As the citation explains, Cape Verde is among the smallest countries in Africa, poorest in natural resources, and yet managed to move its population of 500,000 forward much faster and much further than many other co […]
  • Shout out to Zoneminder Project
    For the first ten years of my open source life, I spent tens of thousands of hours pouring over hundreds of thousands of lines of source code across perhaps a dozen or fewer projects, mostly GCC, G++, GDB, and various other parts of the GNU toolchain. If there were a PhD in open source software, I was definitely specialist enough to have earned one. I was […]
  • OSI Board Members, Officers and Committee Chairs for 2011-2012
    In a special board meeting convened for board elections on March 16 2011, the OSI board elected three new illustrious members of the open source community - Jim Jagielski, Karl Fogel and Mike Godwin. As Simon Phipps posted in his Board Meeting report, the OSI board voted to expand the board from 10 to 11 members to enable all three members to join. Two board […]
  • OSI Board reponds to FCO Questionaire concerning CPTN Transaction
    Towards the end of March, we received a message from the German Bundeskartellamt (Federal Cartel Office or FCO) advising us that the CPTN transaction had been re-notified to them. That means that the consortium seeking to acquire Novell's patent portfolio - Microsoft, Apple, EMC and Oracle - had once again asked for permission to proceed. OSI Concerns […]

1 comment

Comments feed for this article

April 22, 2007 at 1:16 pm

juanita

Well said. I wonder what would happen if Australia captured an American on the grounds of nondescript terrorism?

You must be logged in to post a comment.